G, you know to much to sling that kind of hash. It is a true team game where it is pretty hard to isolate two players and make comparisons that are really valid.Yeah! It's not like Magee scored a bunch of clutch goals in the play-offs last year to lead his team to the MLS Cup.
...and it's not like Luke and Magee didn't play against each other in the play-offs last year and Magee clearly outplayed him and scored more goals or something....
I don't want to get into your guys back and forth. You just picked a bad example.
I do think it is fair to say that Luke probably had a greater positive impact on the Redbulls this year than Magee did for LAG. But that statement doesn't say one is necessarily better than the other. But if I was forming a team and had to pick one or the other, I would pick Luke.
BTW, we traded a better player than either of them to get Magee in the first place, Brad Davis, whom I would pick ahead of Luke in that hypothetical team creation.