I agree with Dan, too early to annoint him, though if we age adjust the stats it is pretty impressive, especially with the fact that there is no "Guevara" feeding him through balls.
One wonders how many he would be scoring if he was 26 or 27.
If he was 27 or 28 he wouldn't be here long enough to hit numbers sufficieint to put him in a Best All Time XI discussion.
One of the good/bad things about this franchise is we dont have many epic longevity performers greater than 4 years or so. So getting on the list isn;t a feat where you would need to play 10 seasons. But if Henry ends up finsihing his career here with 50+ goals and 25+ assists (and perhpas even a trophy) then you would have to look at a guy like Gio or Mathis and ask the question...who deserves to be here more on performance all time with the club?
You could move Mathis to midfield for a while I suppose, but his best ever years with the team were as a forward so we'd be doing it more to preserve his legacy than anything else. I dont have an issue with that as long as someone how clearly as a mdifielder should be there is moved.