Really depends where you're coming from, public transportation for me to get to Yankee stadium is over 2 hours one way. A 4+ hour round trip on public transportation is not something I'm interested in doing and the alternative is a miserable ride in traffic with overpriced parking options just to sit in the upper deck of a stadium with a shit view. I don't blame anyone for not wanting to do that. If we are talking only 30-60 mins each way that's a completely different story.
Also why a lot of current NYC fans never became RB fans..
I'll go if we play them in the playoffs but other then that I'm done going there. Doesn't seem like we gotta worry about ever playing there for open cup since they declined to host anyway.