This talk about Henry started in the original thread because someone suggested that we see have a lot of players who are all about the club because there are no superstars on the team now.
I don't buy that in general, although you can find examples of superstars in this league who got by on reputation rather than effort, but especially not for Henry.
Did his act wear thin for some fans, and maybe for some of his teammates? Evidently.
I think most, especially taking a wide angle view of it, would concede that he earned it before he got here and backed it up on the field while he was here.